If Brookings' plan for Detroit isn't enough to get the job done, what is?
Turning around Detroit means facing head on the core problems that hobble the region, notably:
• America's worst big city race relations
• A population that is too big for current economic reality
• A management and labor culture rooted in an era that no longer exists and is unsuited to the modern economy
• A tax, regulatory, and political system toxic to business
A robust plan for renewal in Detroit will tackle these problems, recognizing that matters like improving race relations and cultural change need indigenous solutions from courageous local leaders. Then mix this with best practices from elsewhere and innovative, unique to Detroit solutions. And be patient, knowing the turnaround won't be a short journey.
1. Repair race relations. The city-suburb divide in Detroit, to an extent far greater than elsewhere, is a matter of black and white. Bringing racial rapprochement won't be easy, but it is an absolute imperative for future regional success. Perhaps a newly shared sense of economic pain can foster this, along with grass roots connections such as white urban gardeners making common cause with black ones seeking better access to fresh foods.
2. Active shrinkage. Many recognize the need for Detroit to “right size” to its reduced population and for federal help doing so. But beyond adjusting to the city's decline, the region remains too big. Detroit no longer needs large armies of unskilled and even skilled laborers in its factories. There is simply no economic raison d'etre for a region the size of Detroit in that location today. A lot more people need to leave Detroit. Many already would like to but can't because they can't sell their house or afford to move. Serious consideration should be given to a federally assisted voluntary relocation program when the national economy recovers to help Detroiters move to Texas or other places with strong jobs growth if they want to. Detroit should also engage with those who did move away to create an urban alumni network. In a globalized economy, those Michigan expatriates can serve as a sort of field sales force for the city.
3. Improve the Business Climate. Michigan's government needs to be downsized to match a downsized state. Dubious programs of all types, from film industry subsidies to “cool cities” initiatives need to be scaled back or eliminated. The criminal justice system should be reformed to stop over-incarcerating non-violent offenders. Streamline or eliminate regulation wherever possible, and make those that remain operate swiftly and predictably. Eliminate or merge overlapping jurisdictions, and especially non-general purpose entities that are too often patronage dumps operating out of the public eye. Reduce taxes on business, especially small business.
4. Change the culture. Michigan's social and business approach, its labor and management culture and business practices were designed for a stable industrial age dominated by a limited number of large and vertically integrated corporations. Today's economy is based around smaller, more innovative, nimble firms, virtual networks of people and collaborative business relationships, rapid change, and a competitive global environment. This sort of change has to come from the inside. No one can just tell Detroit how to do it.
5. Renew Brand Detroit. How does Detroit want to be known in the world and how can it make itself known? Within a framework of shrinkage, Detroit needs to become attractive to the right new talent and new businesses. It needs an aspirational narrative that is authentically Detroit in a way “cool cities” will never be. Cool, No – but edgy? Definitely. Think of Detroit as the new American frontier, a blank canvas where anything is possible, and the ultimate arena in which to pursue alternative visions of urban life. A place where you can pursue a personal urban vision without getting tortured by a Byzantine blizzard of bureaucracy. This should be nourished – and preserved – by maintaining a “light touch” approach to regulation in the city proper. The region is well positioned to attract new urban pioneers and homesteaders, and to leverage its reputation as both a black city and large Arab population center. Detroit should stand proud as “Detroit”. It shouldn't hide behind euphemisms like “Southeastern Michigan” or “The Big D” - as if that fools anybody. Detroit is a name with international recognition and resonance. Wear it with pride.
6. Pursue Targeted Industry Clusters. The auto industry will remain a mainstay in Detroit, particularly management and R&D, though a lot smaller after a federally assisted restructuring. But the city should be wary of overly pursuing “me-too” industries like life sciences without distinctive advantages. Instead, Detroit should look to get its “fair share” of those, then look for where it is positioned to uniquely excel and try to create the environment favorable for investment. Potential targets include:
- A lead role in international trade with Canada.
- Dominating and expanding non-energy/non-financial trade and relations with the Middle East and Muslim world. With America's largest Arab population, Detroit is positioned to be the American gateway to that ever more important part of the globe the way Miami is to Latin America.
- Music. Detroit has one of America's richest and most innovative musical legacies, from Motown to electronica to hip hop. But it hasn't profited from it. Detroit needs to take a page from Nashville and figure out how.
- Realize the Detroit Aerotropolis plan.
- Alternative urban visions. The recipe for grass roots neighborhood renewal in the city, and a potential innovation cluster for any new Detroit ideas that gain widespread adoption.
7. Rationalize Regional Governance and Infrastructure Investment. Detroit should seriously question any expansion of infrastructure when shrinking in regional population. All subsidized infrastructure expansion outside of currently fully urbanized areas should be terminated. It makes no sense to be widening streets on the fringes when you are ripping them out in the city. In this context, the kind of fixed rail investments advocated by Brookings and other “me too” urban boosters should be avoided in this highly decentralized region. Rather, the central city should start with a quality bus network, with rail added later if and only if existing ridership justifies it.
8. Secure Irreplaceable Assets. Detroit built amazing treasures during its golden age, many of them lost or threatened. Detroit has one of the largest collection of pre-War high rises in America. Yet many of them stand vacant. Another gem, the Lafayette Building, is about to be demolished because it is so badly deteriorated, with trees growing on the roof. Some funds need to be earmarked for securing and and supporting basic maintenance such as roof integrity. While there may not be demand to reuse these structures now, they are irreplaceable and should be saved for future generations. On the cultural side, Detroit needs to ask itself tough questions about institutions like the Detroit Institute of the Arts and the Detroit Symphony Orchestra that are bleeding red ink.
The road back for Detroit won't be short or easy. It will certainly not be back as the colossus of its past. But Detroit can grasp a more successful future if it finds the courage and the leadership to change, and to find a unique path forward for a city that is simply not like anyplace else in the world. Conventional wisdom solutions are just not enough. It will take radical change, new attitudes and an ability to think independently about what’s best for the region.
|
|
The Brookings Plan |
The Urbanophile Plan |
|
Race Relations |
Segregation is acknowledged |
Improving race relations is a top imperative |
|
Regional Governance |
Strong Regionalism Featuring: |
Adopt Brookings Plan |
|
Brand Positioning |
N/A |
- “The New American Frontier”, the land of possibility, a blank canvas, and the ultimate arena in which to realize alternative and new visions of urban life. |
|
Economic Development Paradigm |
Government industrial policy |
Improve the business climate |
|
Fiscal Policy |
N/A |
- Downsize all level of government to match a downsized Michigan and Detroit |
|
Regulatory Reform |
N/A |
- Seek out and eliminate rules without a clear rationale and net benefits, esp. ones that negatively affect the business climate |
|
Target Economic Sectors |
- Advanced Manufacturing / Auto-Related R&D |
- Advanced Manufacturing / Auto-Related R&D |
|
Auto Industry Future |
Federally assisted restructuring |
Adopt Brookings Plan |
|
Management & Labor Culture; Regional Business Practices |
N/A |
Urgent change is prerequisite to success |
|
Human Capital Targets |
N/A |
- New Urban Pioneers |
|
Adjusting to Population Loss |
- Government sponsored footprint shrinkage |
Adopt Brookings Plan and Supplement With |
|
Transportation |
Rail transit |
- Terminate highway and other infrastructure expansion outside of fully developed areas |
|
Historic Preservation |
N/A |
- Inventory and invest to secure and “mothball” key historic structures, esp. pre-War downtown high rises |
Aaron M. Renn is an independent writer on urban affairs based in the Midwest. His writings appear at The Urbanophile.
Email this Story
friso
Friso Moments là một chương trình ưu đãi dành cho những người mới làm mẹ và mua sản phẩm Friso. Hãy tích lũy điểm và đổi lấy những phần quà thú vị.
Với những bí quyết lựa chọn và chế biến món ăn hấp dẫn từ ứng dụng của Friso, cùng thành phần dinh dưỡng hữu ích, mẹ sẽ không còn phải lo lắng khi bé ...
chuyên cung cấp sữa Friso
chất lượng, nguồn gốc rõ ràng với mức giá tốt nhất. Mua sữa ở để tích điểm đổi quà cho bé.Cung cấp sữa bột Friso các loại cho trẻ sơ sinh, trẻ từ 1 đến 3 tuổi, trên 3 tuổi… Các dòng sữa chính hãng giá tốt nhất, ưu đãi hấp dẫn cho mẹ và bé khi mua!
This is very educational
This is very educational content and written well for a change. It's nice to see that some people still understand how to write a quality post.!
Click 10 Cent Avos Link
Yes i am totally agreed with
Yes i am totally agreed with this article and i just want say that this article is very nice and very informative article.I will make sure to be reading your blog more. You made a good point but I can't help but wonder, what about the other side? !!!!!!THANKS!!!!!!
Ivy League tutor
I high appreciate this post.
I high appreciate this post. It’s hard to find the good from the bad sometimes, but I think you’ve nailed it! would you mind updating your blog with more information?
hack facebook online
This is such a great
This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing websites that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free. It is the old what goes around comes around routine.
Relationship Tips by Quartier Restaurant
Thanks for the blog loaded
Thanks for the blog loaded with so many information. Stopping by your blog helped me to get what I was looking for.
online distance courses
Music Branding Vs. the Arts
I agree with Aaron that branding Detroit as a music and entertainment center is a legitimate avenue to pursue in cultural tourism, but perhaps music is just part of a larger cultural tourism plan. (Have you been to Hitsville U.S.A.? Not exactly like walking down 6th street in Austin.) As a visual artist I see incredible potential in Detroit for artists. Precisely because the city needs so much help, there are abundant opportunities for artists to initiate meaningful socio-cultural projects.
Many cities are offering incentives to artists in order to generate cultural capital that will encourage redevelopment and commerce. I think the combination of inexpensive real estate, low cost of living, and underdog status of Detroit provide the right conditions to attract artists.
I have no hard evidence that an influx of artists would truly help the city other than to make it an interesting cultural destination, but anecdotally inexpensive real estate has helped formerly struggling, sprawling, industrial, urban centers like Berlin and Brooklyn become cultural crown jewels. I would love to see a 100 year graph of the property value in Park Slope, Brooklyn. I spent 2007-09 living in Richmond, VA, a city which is increasingly investing in its urban core. While there is significant sprawl in that city, 20 and 30 something artists moving into the downtown area creating cultural destinations attracted business to follow. I saw this working, boarded up store fronts turned into galleries, 6 months or a year later it was a restaurant or a boutique.
Not that encouraging gentrification in Detroit is any kind of real solution, far from it. But any positive cultural projects or growth in the city should be encouraged. You can attract businesses with incentives, but if you don't have the traffic those businesses will likely fail. Also, if improving race relations is a top priority then supporting the arts and contemporary artists is an absolute no brainer. Art is neosporin on Detroit's racial wounds.
Cultural tourism starts with human assets. I would like to see bringing those assets to Detroit become an important part of any plan. Moving to Detroit is seriously on my mind...
Detroit can be...
I grew up in Windsor and have nothing but hope for the city of Detroit. I believe that the city administration needs to break the city down into a grid like pattern to better understand how to scale down. Once this has been completed they can then identify the areas which contain the lowest population and relocate those people to the downtown core. The potential savings from the reduction in servicing those areas (water, transit, policing, etc.) could potentially out weigh the relocation costs. This of course could be done on a long term basis with proper planning and budgeting.
Detroit astride the border
Aaron
The idea of Detroit's economy benefiting from its position at the most significant crossing to Canada is worth further discussion. When I look at the great, complex, romantic and wealthy city of Istanbul at the best crossing point on the Bosporus I imagine what Detroit was and might be again. The economies on the heavily populated land masses on each side of the Detroit River could enrich Detroit as they once did not so long ago.But first we need to understand how Detroit damaged its economic status as border trading post.
What happened? As with so many things Detroit the wound was self inflicted- the last cut coming during Clinton's 2nd term. In winter 1997 when I was mayor I met with Rodney Slater, the new USDOT Secretary, for breakfast at Milwaukee's Pfister Hotel. Rodney was on a nationwide tour by Winnebago Caravan to introduce himself to mayors and state DOT secretaries. He had just come from Detroit and a meeting with then Mayor Dennis Archer. Sec. Slater declared that he had just granted Archer's #1 priority- closing the gap between the end of the Ambassador Bridge and Michigan's vast freeway system.
The Gap was a few block strip where a traveler might buy a tank of gas, a candy bar, cigarets or maybe a Tiger tee shirt.The Mayor and his Public Works department apparently felt that travelers should not even slow down in Detroit; that traffic throughput was a higher priority than retail sales. So now people buy their gas,cigs and tee shirts somewhere else. Archer's #1 priority was the wrong priority just as MichDOT's focus on fighting congestion is the wrong priority. The DOT has won its fight in Detroit. Congestion is no longer much of a problem. My advice to Detroit is to try to regain congestion and not just traffic congestion, but people and money congestion.
Embrace urbanism and the complexity that goes with it. That means adopting pro urban form based coding, restoring damaged parts of Detroit's street grid and adding as much transit as can be paid for with foundation and government resources. It means that any new bridge to Canada should enter the city's at grade street grid and not immediately hook into the Michigan Sprawlway system. Any bridges should accommodate pedestrians and bicycles.
Detroit is not doomed. It is just badly damaged. With people like you focused on a positive future for the city I'm even more confident that Detroit can rise, not like Phoenix( which actually may be doomed)but like strategically placed cities throughout history that have been bombed, sacked and ruined only to rebuild. Just 60 years ago Detroit was one of the richest most successful cities on the planet. It could be again.
The challenge with Detroit
The challenge with Detroit is that there are very few functions for which the city is suited. If it can't take advantage of its concentrated manufacturing skills to lead on electric cars, I'm not sure what the city is for. Cities can and do die when they no longer have a purpose, and the idea of bailing people out of their mortgages has a whiff of emergency services about it. It's the financial equivalent of the fire department, as the task is very much like helping people escape a burning building. The assumption is that the building, Detroit, is already mostly a loss.
Detroit has one other interesting possibility. It's the only major city located directly on the US-Canada border. I'd be interested on your views about whether there are certain aspects of international trade that are only viable when the two countries are in the same urban region. Are there aspects of international trade that still benefit from a place where both sides of the deal can meet in person on a routine basis?
Jarrett Walker
Senior Consultant
McCormick Rankin Cagney
Blog: www.HumanTransit.org